Initial Thoughts: The cover looks like a children's book. That was my first thought when I saw it in the library. Upon further investigation I suppose it doesn't. It looks very steampunk-y. You're going to notice that I really like Steampunk, both as a genre and as a style. What made me think it was a children's book was the fact that it is yellow (the color of old paper) with a fair amount of red in it... And it had a horse on it that looks like a toy but if you look more carefully you'll see that it's actually a springpunk horse that is used instead of (or in addition to) car-like transportation.
Yeah, I totally misjudged the book from the title. Fortunately, I had enough sense to request this book from the publisher, even though it looked like a children's book and I am very happy I did. If I hadn't, I may never have gotten around to reading it and that would have been a crying shame. Which brings me to:
The Good!
Sanderson created an entire world, religion, and way of life. It was quite impressive, really, that he came up with so much. It may not be as thorough as a book like Game of Thrones but it was incredibly well thought out and detailed. For instance, the book takes place in the "Isles of America" where there are 60 states that are all independent island, which meant that for me, as an American, it was relatively easy to picture in my head where everything was. But, even if you're not familiar with America, there is an easy fix! Open to the cover of the book and you'll find a map of the America's Isles and the location of eight other (presumably) Rithmatist Academies. Sanderson never touched on the other schools, though, so I'm assuming that that will be addressed in his further books (can it please be 2017 yet?).
He invented his own kind of genre--Springpunk--which is pretty much like Steampunk except with, you know, springs as the mechanism that moves their technology as opposed to the main form of power being steam. There are pieces of Steampunk involved with this book. There's an emphasis on clocks and gears, which may actually be more than what they seem.
I loved the degree of separation between the Rithmatists and the "normal" folk. It was like high school all over again and perfectly believable. Had everyone gotten along I would have been disappointed. This arrangement made it all the more plausible
The Bad:
The fact that there wasn't as much action as I would have liked. The ending is amazing, I kept tossing and turning as I read in my bed because it was giving me so much energy with all the action. But, unfortunately, there is not enough action throughout the book. For the topic to be about magical warriors there wasn't enough fighting. I really wish we had gotten to see the liveliness of Nebrask.
But, quite frankly, that's the only negative thing I could think of.
Be ye warned, spoilers ahead!
I would have said in the first half of this book that he was certainly going to become one because he had the makings of a true Rithmatist and his fascination with them. Perhaps he would be like me, at twenty-four I still haven't gotten my letter of admission to Hogwarts but I know it'll happen someday.
I'm betting that that boy is going to get the powers of a Rithmatist and totes own the stage. But then why, at the end, did his lines not move? Sanderson is killing me, man. I need Joel to be a Rithmatist!
I absolutely love the connection that forms between Joel and Melody. It has the potential to become romantic but it wasn't even the slightest; they were just good friends who shared fun/dangerous times together. Ultimately I do think it's going to turn romantic, but we won't find out until about 2017. Ugh.




